top of page

What Happens to SEO When Consumers Start Searching Through AI Assistants?

6 hours ago
8 min read

Industry & Competitive Context

For two decades, brand discovery online has rested on a simple exchange: a consumer types a query, a search engine returns a ranked list of links, and brands compete, through search engine optimization (SEO), to be among the links clicked. Google’s parent, Alphabet, has been the dominant intermediary in that exchange, and its Search business remains the largest revenue line in its filings. In the quarter ended September 30, 2026, Alphabet reported total revenues of $127.6 billion, up 25% year over year, and Google Search & other revenues of $63.35 billion, up 12% from $56.57 billion a year earlier. In the same release, CEO Sundar Pichai said Search’s year-over-year query growth rate was the highest in the last five years.

Two shifts are now reshaping this exchange. First, Google itself has placed AI-generated summaries (AI Overviews) above its traditional results. Second, standalone AI assistants have become a parallel route to answers. OpenAI has said ChatGPT reached 1.2 billion weekly active users, up from 1 billion roughly 60 days earlier, and that ChatGPT’s search activity runs at about one-fifth of Google’s query volume. Both claims came from an OpenAI executive speaking at an OpenAI-hosted event in November 2026. OpenAI has not published the underlying data or named the Google baseline it used. Independent estimates cited in the same coverage, from Ahrefs and SEOClarity, put ChatGPT search volume between 7.5% and 12% of Google’s. The gap between the company’s claim and the third-party range is itself a finding: even the scale of the shift is contested.

The competitive question for brands is therefore not whether AI-mediated search exists, but how much of the discovery journey it has captured and what that does to the value of ranking in a list of links.


Graphic about SEO and AI assistants: phone shows ChatGPT laptop recommendations, Google search icons, and a laptop with falling SEO graph.

Brand Situation Prior to the Shift

This case examines a market-wide transition rather than a single brand’s campaign, so there is no single protagonist. The relevant starting position is the one most brands occupied before AI summaries became common. Their digital discovery strategy treated a high organic ranking as the main route to traffic, and traffic as the main route to conversion. SEO investment was therefore justified by click volume.

In February 2024, Gartner publicly predicted that traditional search engine volume would fall 25% by 2026 because of AI chatbots and other virtual agents. Analyst Alan Antin was quoted attributing the decline to these agents taking over search marketing share. This was a forecast, not a measurement. No verified public information is available on whether the predicted 25% decline has occurred, and Alphabet’s own most recent results (query growth at a five-year high, Search revenue up 12%) do not show a decline in Google Search activity. The prediction is best read as an early statement of the concern that has since shaped brand planning, not as an established outcome.


Strategic Objective

For brands and agencies, the objective that follows from this environment is to preserve discoverability and demand capture when the consumer’s first answer comes from an AI-generated summary or assistant rather than a click-through list.

McKinsey’s October 2025 analysis, “New front door to the internet: Winning in the age of AI search,” frames this as a capability to build, which it calls generative engine optimization (GEO). Its recommendations are to diagnose current performance and value at risk, rebalance content investment across owned, third-party and community sources, optimize content so AI systems can surface it, and treat GEO as a core capability with its own KPIs and a cross-functional team. These are one consultancy’s recommendations, not an industry standard. They do, however, show how a leading advisory firm defines the strategic problem: visibility inside the answer, not only position on the page.


Campaign Architecture & Execution

There is no single campaign here, so this section examines how the response is structured rather than describing an initiative. Two sets of actors have made documented moves.

Platforms have changed the search results page. Google has integrated AI summaries into search, and McKinsey reported that about 50% of Google searches already include AI summaries, a share it expects to exceed 75% by 2028. That 2028 figure is McKinsey’s projection, not an observed result. Pew Research Center’s browsing study, covering March 2025, found a lower prevalence at that earlier date: 18% of the Google searches it observed produced an AI summary, and 58% of participants had at least one such search. The two figures measure different samples and dates, so they should not be treated as a trend line.

Brands, meanwhile, have been slow to institutionalize a response. In a McKinsey survey of roughly 30 Fortune 500 consumer brand CMOs in September 2025, only 16% reported systematically tracking AI search performance. The sample is small, so the figure indicates the state of practice among large brands rather than a market-wide rate.



Positioning & Consumer Insight

The consumer insight behind the shift is that people increasingly treat the answer, not the list of links, as the product. McKinsey’s August 2025 US consumer survey (n = 1,927) found that half of respondents now intentionally seek out AI-powered search engines. Among AI-search users, 44% said it is their primary and preferred source of insight, compared with 31% for traditional search, 9% for retailer or brand websites, and 6% for review sites. This is self-reported preference in a single US survey, but it points to a strategic risk: brand-owned sites are being ranked below an AI layer in the consumer’s own hierarchy of trusted sources.

McKinsey’s source analysis sharpens that risk. It found that brands’ own sites make up only 5 to 10% of the sources that AI search references, and that in consumer packaged goods and financial services, over 65% of AI-search sources are publishers, user-generated content and affiliates. The positioning implication is that a brand’s presence in an AI answer depends heavily on what others say about it, not only on what it publishes. This reframes SEO from a site-optimization discipline into a reputation and content-distribution discipline.


Media & Channel Strategy

Because the shift is structural, the verified channel evidence concerns how consumer behaviour at the search interface has changed, and how disputed the effect on website traffic is.

The most rigorous public behavioural data comes from Pew Research Center, which tracked the browsing activity of 900 US adults and 68,879 Google searches in March 2025. Users who encountered an AI summary clicked a traditional result link in 8% of visits, compared with 15% of visits without one. Only 1% of visits to pages with an AI summary included a click on a link inside the summary. Users ended their browsing session after 26% of pages with AI summaries, versus 16% of pages without. Pew reported these as observed behaviours; any “percentage reduction” derived from the 8% and 15% figures is a calculation, not a Pew finding.

Other documented measurements point the same way but come from different sources. Press Gazette reported research by Authoritas, submitted to the UK Competition and Markets Authority, showing per-query click-through rates down 47.5% on desktop and 37.7% on mobile when an AI Overview is present. It also reported Similarweb data showing zero-click news searches rising from 56% to almost 69% between May 2024 and May 2025. These measure behaviour at the results page, not total publisher traffic or revenue.

Google disputes the broader conclusion. In a blog post dated August 6, 2025, Liz Reid, Google’s VP and Head of Search, stated that total organic click volume from Google Search to websites has been “relatively stable year-over-year” and that Google is sending “slightly more quality clicks” than a year ago, defined as clicks where users do not quickly return to the results. The post provided no percentages or absolute figures. Press Gazette’s reporting noted that SEO practitioners and several publishers described declining clicks in their own analytics, but supplied no quantified data in that coverage.

The verified record is therefore contested rather than conclusive. Behavioural studies show fewer clicks per search when AI summaries appear, while Google reports stable overall click volume without disclosing data.


Business & Brand Outcomes

Documented outcomes are limited, and most quantified figures about the future are forecasts. For clarity, they are separated here.

Observed results: Alphabet’s Search & other revenue grew 12% year over year in the September 2026 quarter, and Alphabet reported record-pace query growth. Pew’s study documents lower click rates and more session endings when AI summaries appear. Press Gazette reported lower per-query click-through (Authoritas) and higher zero-click news search rates (Similarweb) in the presence of AI features.

Forecasts and projections: McKinsey projects that $750 billion in US revenue will flow through AI-powered search by 2028 and states that brands that do not prepare may see traditional search traffic fall by 20 to 50%. It also notes that leaders’ GEO performance may lag their SEO performance by 20 to 50%. These are McKinsey’s projections and analysis, not realized outcomes. Gartner’s 2024 prediction of a 25% decline in traditional search volume by 2026 is likewise a forecast.


Strategic Implications

First, the unit of competition is shifting from the link to the citation. Pew’s click data and McKinsey’s source data together indicate that, when an AI summary appears, the answer is the destination, and the brands inside the answer, not the ranked links beneath it, capture attention. SEO’s core logic, earning a click by ranking, weakens where fewer clicks follow a search. Whether that effect holds at scale is contested, since Google reports stable click volume. Brands should plan for the possibility rather than for certainty.

Second, third-party presence becomes strategically central. If, as McKinsey found, brand-owned sites account for only 5 to 10% of AI-cited sources and publishers, user-generated content and affiliates dominate in sectors such as CPG and financial services, then earned and third-party content carries more weight in discoverability than most brand content budgets reflect. This shifts value toward public relations, reviews, community presence and partnerships, functions often organizationally separate from SEO.

Third, measurement lags behavior. With only 16% of surveyed large-brand CMOs tracking AI search performance, and no public, standardized, audited metric for AI-answer visibility, firms are making resource decisions with weaker instrumentation than they have for classic SEO. The risk is less that AI search is large than that it cannot yet be measured.

Fourth, claims about scale should be weighed by source. OpenAI’s statement that ChatGPT search runs at about 20% of Google’s volume sits well above the 7.5% to 12% estimated by independent firms, and OpenAI has not released its data. Alphabet’s own results show Search still growing. A prudent strategy treats AI assistants as a fast-growing additional discovery channel, not as proof that traditional search is in decline.

Finally, the platform owners’ incentives differ from the brands’. Google reports that AI in Search drives more queries and higher-quality clicks; brands and publishers report less traffic. Both can be partly true, since a platform can grow overall usage while individual sites see less per search. No verified public information is available that resolves this at the level of an individual brand’s traffic.


Discussion Questions

  1. Pew’s browsing data shows lower click rates when an AI summary appears, while Google states that total organic click volume has been relatively stable. What additional, independently verifiable data would a CMO need to decide whether to reduce, maintain or increase SEO investment?

  2. McKinsey found that brand-owned sites make up only 5 to 10% of AI-cited sources and that third-party sources dominate in sectors such as CPG and financial services. How should this change the allocation of budget and organizational responsibility among SEO, public relations, reviews and community management?

  3. OpenAI’s claim that ChatGPT search equals about 20% of Google’s volume differs sharply from the 7.5% to 12% estimated by independent firms. How should a strategist weigh platform-reported figures against third-party estimates when sizing a new discovery channel?

  4. Alphabet reported Search revenue growth of 12% and record-pace query growth in the same period in which brands and publishers report lower clicks. Explain how both can be true, and discuss which stakeholders benefit and which bear the cost of AI summaries.

  5. Only 16% of surveyed large consumer brands systematically track AI search performance, and no standardized public metric for AI-answer visibility exists. What KPIs would you propose for a GEO function, and what are the limits of each given the absence of audited data?

Comments


bottom of page